Supervisor Tom Croci

Historic Islip Trail

Islip Town has a long and rich history, dating back to its founding in 1683, by William Nicoll. It is a seaside community, with deep roots in fishing, boating and farming, but is also home to Long Island’s original Gold Coast, where esteemed families such as the Roosevelts and Vanderbilts had luxurious summer estates, and Blue Point Oysters were made world famous.

The Historic Islip Trail Map has been established to help identify some of Islip’s most significant historical sites. This map indentifies more than 30 places of historical interest to the area, including Sagtikos Manor in Bay Shore; the Bayard Cutting Arboretum in Great River; and the Long Island Maritime Museum in West Sayville. But there are so many more!

Click on any one of the photos in the gallery below, or on the Google Maps link, to find out where Islip Town’s historic places of interest are located. Information includes a brief historical summary and contact information for each historic site.

We encourage you to review this Historical Map and then take time out of your busy schedule to visit these significant and interesting places, that help to identify why and how Islip became the great Town that it is today! Check each individual listing for important information about accessibility, as all are not open to the public, but can still be viewed curbside.

Map out your tour on Google        

View Historic Videos

Download the Historic Map
  • 1. La Grange Inn
  • 2. Fire Island Lighthouse
  • 3. Arnold Manor
  • 4. Sagtikos Manor
  • 5. Vitagraph Studios
  • 6. Gibson-Mack-Holt House
  • 7. Bay Shore Post Office
  • 8. First Congregational Church
  • 9. United Methodist Church
  • 10. Second Avenue Firehouse
  • 11. The Guastavino Tile House
  • 12. Modern Times School
  • 13. America's Cup Way
  • 14. 14. Wereholme, Weekes Estate; Skully Estate, Seatuck
  • 15. Islip Town Hall
  • 16. Brookwood Hall
  • 17. Central Islip Civic Center
  • 18. Bayard Cutting Arboretum
  • 19. Southside Sportsmen’s Club / Snedecor’s Tavern
  • 20. Idle Hour Estate
  • 21. Jacob Ockers House
  • 22. St. John's Episcopal Church
  • 23. Bourne Mansion
  • 24. Long Island Maritime Museum
  • 25. Gillette House
  • 26. Edwards Homestead
  • 27. Sayville Congregational Church
  • 28. St. Ann’s Episcopal Church
  • 29. Meadow Croft Estate
  • 30. Bayport Aerodrome
  • 31. Father Divine's Peace Mission
  • 32. The Islip Grange